Pies
Hartville Kitchen offers a wide variety pie flavors to delight the tastebuds. We offer cream pies and baked pies in several traditional flavors. We also have seasonal fresh fruit pies, depending on the time of year.
How It's Made
Cream Pies
Banana Meringue
Fresh bananas sliced in the bottom of the crust and filled with banana pudding and topped with toasted meringue. Also Available in Small Pie.
Butterscotch Meringue
Butterscotch pudding topped with toasted meringue. Also Available in Small Pie.
Chocolate Meringue
Chocolate pudding topped with toasted meringue. Also Available in Small Pie.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream
Peanut butter crumbs coat the bottom of the crust and are topped with chocolate pudding and more peanut butter crumbs. This is then topped with whipped cream and sprinkled with more peanut butter crumbs on top. Also Available in Small Pie.
Coconut Meringue
Coconut pudding, with untoasted coconut flakes throughout, topped with toasted meringue and toasted coconut flakes. Also Available in Small Pie.
Lemon Meringue
Tart lemon pudding topped with toasted meringue. Also Available in Small Pie.
Mixed Berry Cream
Vanilla pudding topped with mixed berry filling and finished off with whipped cream. Not seedless. Also Available in Small Pie.
Vanilla Peanut Butter Cream
Peanut butter crumbs coat the bottom of the crust and are topped with vanilla pudding and more peanut butter crumbs. This is then topped with whipped cream and sprinkled with more peanut butter crumbs on top. Also Available in Small Pie.
Baked Pies
Apple
A double-crusted apple pie made with Jonathan apples and our homemade pie filling. Also Available in Small Pie.
Blueberry
A double-crusted blueberry pie made with blueberries and our homemade filling.
Cherry
A double-crusted cherry pie made with tart Montgomery cherries and our homemade pie filling. Also Available in Small Pie.
Cherry Crumb
Pie made with tart Montgomery cherries and our homemade pie filling and then topped with a crumb topping.
Custard
A baked egg custard pie with a browned top.
Dutch Apple
Pie made with Jonathan apples and our homemade pie filling and then topped with a crumb topping.
Mixed Berry
A double-crusted pie made with mixed berries and our homemade filling. (Not Seedless)
Peach
A double-crusted peach pie made with yellow cling peaches and our homemade filling.
Pecan
A sweet and rich pie with toasted pecan pieces that cover the top when baked.
Pumpkin
Perfectly spiced pumpkin pie with whipped egg whites to create a darker brown top to give it a nice custard-like texture.
Rhubarb Crumb
A tart rhubarb pie that uses rhubarb that is incorporated into a custard-like filling and topped with a crumb topping.
Sugar-Free Apple
A double-crusted apple pie made with Jonathan apples and our homemade filling that uses Splenda instead of sugar. No sugar added. Also Available in Small Pie.
Sugar-Free Cherry
A double-crusted cherry pie made with tart Montgomery cherries and our homemade filling that uses Splenda instead of sugar. No sugar added. Also Available in Small Pie.
Seasonal Pies
Fresh Strawberry
Available Easter through Labor Day. Fresh sliced strawberries coated in a strawberry glaze and topped with whipped cream.
Key Lime
Available in the Spring. The perfect balance of tart and sweet this traditional style key lime pie is topped with whipped cream and fresh limes.