cinnamon rolls

Baked Goods

If you’re looking for a delectable dessert or treat to enjoy later, be sure to stop by our bakery. Every day, our bakers are busy mixing the freshest ingredients into amazing creations. Just follow your nose to our bakery counter!
breads on a rack


There’s nothing quite like the smell of fresh baked bread! Head over to our bakery counter and you’ll find over 8 varieties of fresh homemade breads.
m&m cookies on a rake


Follow the tantalizing aroma to our bakery where you will find a wide array of fresh-baked cookies. All your favorite cookie flavors are available, including Whoopie Pies which have filling choices for different days of the week.
a beautifully decorated cake with yellow lilies, pink lupins, and butterflies

Decorated Cakes

Celebrate life’s special moments with a professionally decorated cake from our bakery. We can design the perfect cake for you or we can transfer the image of a favorite photograph onto your cake giving it a more personal effect.
coconut cream cake on a cake stand with a piece missing

Dessert Cakes

Our decadent dessert cakes are sure to please your guests for any event. Many double-layer cake varieties are available.
chocolate peanut butter pie on a plate


Hartville Kitchen Bakery offers a wide variety of pie flavors to delight the tastebuds. We offer cream pies and baked pies in several flavors. We also offer seasonal flavors.
a beautiful rustic wedding cake

Wedding Cakes

Complete your wedding day with a beautiful cake from Hartville Kitchen. Our decadent flavors paired with unique designs will undoubtedly charm your guests. We have 3 full time professional cake decorators on staff!

Looking for a Custom Design?

With five full time professional cake decorators on staff, Hartville Kitchen offers beautiful bakery designs that will leave your guests wanting more. If you can imagine it, we can create it!

Contact Us